Fish Predation, Not Flows, Causing Salmon Death on Tuolumne

Tuolumne River Trust -

A new federal study indicates that 93 percent of juvenile salmon deaths on the Tuolumne River are caused by predation from non-native fish species, rather than insufficient water flows.

The report could have major implications in halting a controversial State Water Resources Control Board proposal which looks to take irrigation water from farmers to benefit salmon spawning runs, potentially shuttering hundreds of family farms.

The Water Board plan would require the Turlock and Modesto Irrigation Districts to send 35 percent of Tuolumne River flows from February 1 through June 30 down the river, losing hundreds of thousands of acre-feet of irrigation water they would have otherwise diverted to Don Pedro Reservoir.

“There is a disconnect between the Water Board’s theory about what might help the Delta and what trained scientists are finding in the field,” said Allen Short, executive director of the San Joaquin Tributaries Authority. “No matter how much water we send down the river, if nothing is done to prevent the striped bass and other non-native predators from eating young salmon, the population will never recover. If the Water Board is serious about restoring the salmon population, predation must be addressed in an aggressive and comprehensive way.”

The report was prepared as part of TID and MID's ongoing effort to relicense Don Pedro Dam. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, which oversees dams, required the testing.

According to the SJTA, researchers estimated the numbers of predatory fish, analyzed their stomach contents, and tracked juvenile salmon as they swam toward the ocean. The report shows that 93 percent of the smolt are simply eaten.

The findings contradict the Water Board proposal, which does not mention predation as a factor contributing to juvenile salmon death. The proposal argues only that higher river flows are needed to increase native salmon populations.

However, Water Board experts admit they are unsure how much difference the increased flows will make.

“We don't know what kind of natural production we're going to get until we start increasing flows to see what natural production we can achieve,” said Dean Marsten, Fishery Program Manager with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife, when testifying before the Water Board on Nov. 13, 2012.

Anti-predation programs have been successful in other regions. A Columbia River Basin program, offering incentives to fishermen who catch predator species, has led to a 30 percent increase in juvenile salmon survival rates, per the SJTA.

“It makes no sense to permit the destruction of 93 percent of the salmon smolt population on a key Delta tributary without taking the slightest measures to mitigate the problem,” Short said. “Unlike the continual increases in flow, which has failed to reverse salmon population declines, predator suppression works and should be a top priority for the Water Board.”

The report, released on Jan. 17, could become a lynchpin in the SJTA's expected legal action to prevent the water take. SJTA legal counsel Tim O'Laughlin said earlier this month that an “aggressive approach” will likely lead to legal action coming “early and often.” It could take as long as 15 years before the matter is decided in court, he said.

Though the legal action will be lengthy and costly, it pales in comparison to the potential economic impact of the Water Board's proposed reductions. SJTA projects the water loss would lead to a $180 million economic impact in dry years, including the loss of over 1,200 jobs and 800 family farms.

Comments 3

  1. Brilliant says:
    Brilliant concept. How much did it cost to pay for this genius idea that salmon smolt are being eaten by predatory fish?
  2. SF Evolution says:
    SF liberals believe in evolution but they keep fighting to save a little fish? People need the water!!!
    • evolution, please. says:
      your comment about evolution is irrelevant, and honestly quite ignorant. it's not only liberals in san francisco who believe in evolution...pretty much anyone with a brain who knows how to use it knows that evolution is true. if you believe in god, shouldn't you be interested in saving all his creatures? i mean if 'creation' is true...then there would be more of an emphasis from those who believe in 'creation' to save those fish, since they would technically be crafts of god. just sayin'...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Recent Forum Topics

Recent Forum Replies

  • paul on In what different materials do women’s activewear comes? "You may get a variety of fabrics for the best activewear for women online, including cotton, spandex, synthetic, bamboo fiber, and Gore-Tex. Each of these materials has distinctive properties that set them apart. Since polyester is incredibly light and comfortable to wear, we advise you to utilize it. Athletic clothing frequently uses polyester as a fabric. Shirts for activewear, sweatpants and jogging jackets usually contain polyester blends. Polyester often dries quickly, making it the perfect fabric for intense workouts."
  • PaulWatkins on How does a real estate agency work? "Hi Dans Andrew, I'm glad you have made the right decision because a real estate agency is a promising career. Real estate agency involves dealing with properties either for selling or purchasing. When a client comes to a real estate agency to sell a property, it is the estate agent's job to find a buyer. If the agent finds a buyer and closes the deal at a good price for both parties, the estate agent gets a 1% commission from both buyer and seller. This is how real estate agencies work, and estate agents earn."
  • dans on Where can we find the best kratom capsules? "Hi, sir, I don't know which state you live in because many states in the U.S. have prohibited the sale of the best kratom capsules, but you can still find them online. Many online pharmaceutical stores provide the best kratom capsules at affordable prices. You can look for such online stores on Google or even social media. The store will deliver the best kratom capsule to your home without charging the delivery charges."
  • dans on How to choose the right weight loss clinic? "A reputable weight loss clinic should preferably include counseling while being overseen by a doctor or other qualified medical expert. However, some weight-loss facilities allow clients to quickly obtain weight-loss medications and leave without providing a thorough medical history or seeking a physician's opinion. You should stay away from these types of locations because they're dangerous and probably won't result in long-term weight loss. Find a facility that focuses on the behavioral treatment or lifestyle counseling instead. They can provide you with the tools you need to make healthy decisions and advice on how to fit exercise into your daily schedule. Some of these tactics include keeping track of your meals and keeping a weekly workout log."
  • paul on Why are customer reviews important during online shopping? "The most crucial component of every online store is its customer reviews. Reviews can assist other customers in determining whether or not the business and its items are worthwhile purchases. If you earn positive evaluations, your brand will gain an enormous reputation and rank better on Google. According to Google's recently modified algorithm, a business can increase its performance by obtaining reviews. This is the rationale behind inquiries about reviews on Google, Facebook, and other online clothing stores for women."
Skip to content