Backyard Buildings Too Big? Turlock Planning Commission to Talk Regulations

Courtesy of the City of Turlock

In Turlock’s Summerfaire neighborhood, one enormous backyard building has stirred up a Turlock Planning Commission review of the regulations covering such structures.

Ken Oyer moved in to his home 20 years ago, drawn to the Summerfaire neighborhood’s nice atmosphere and then-new construction. Recently, though, a new neighbor moved in – a young family, with a business run from the home.

“We like the family,” Oyer said. “They don’t like us any more.”

The dispute began as the neighbor gradually began to accumulate more and more work equipment. A truck was soon joined by a bucket truck, then a trailer, then a canvas-tented workspace.

Then, out of nowhere, came an enormous permanent building.

“All of the sudden we woke up one morning and there was a sheet metal building,” Oyer said.

The building stands 16 feet tall at its peak, and covers 480 square feet. And the building sits just five feet from Oyer’s backyard fence, dominating his view. Now, usually, you’d see these buildings built on farming land, construction sites or warehouse plots, so it’s definitely an unfamiliar site in somebody’s backyard. Even if they used the best metal buildings iowa has to offer, it may still look out of place in such a confined space.

“It’s apparently legal for him to build this monstrosity,” Oyer said. “He calls it a garage.

“It’s not a garage. It’s not intended to be a garage … This is a sheet metal warehouse.”

The building simply doesn’t fit in a residential backyard, Oyer said. It’s not just the size, it’s the facade, he says, which looks like something from an industrial park.

The Turlock Planning Commission agrees: the building seems out of keeping with a residential neighborhood.

“I wouldn’t be happy,” said Planning Commissioner Soraya Fregosi.

But the building meets current codes. There’s nothing Turlock can do, other than ensure the neighbor uses the building as permitted.

Oyer’s predicament come as the Turlock Planning Commission begins a review of local laws governing accessory structures. Those “accessory structures” can refer to anything from pool houses to gazebos, tree houses, or – yes – “garages.”

As the law is currently written, accessory buildings up to 16 feet in height can be as close as 5 feet from a neighbor’s fence, regardless of square footage, so long as the eave slopes down to 10 feet. The rule was drafted to promote sloping roof lines, minimizing visibility beyond fences.

But the law doesn’t handle buildings with flat roofs well, or multiple structures on one property. There are no provisions for aesthetics, or capping the square-footage used for accessory structures.

“At some point, exceeding certain limits, it’s impacting your community and the people living around you,” said Planning Commissioner Ashour Badal. “There’s got to be a broader discussion.”

And the law doesn’t differentiate between pergolas or warehouses. Even vine trellises or carports are subject to the law, and require permits.

The Turlock Planning Commission began their review of the accessory building code on Thursday. Over the next few months, all of the inconsistencies are expected to be hammered out through a series of workshops.

Eventually, the code will be modified to set harder limits, which will likely allow for only shorter, smaller accessory structures.

“I think we’re seeing a need to look at something that’s a little lower,” Turlock Planning Manager Debbie Whitmore said.

Comments 7

  1. Turlockian says:
    I can understand his complaint. I wouldn't want to see that from my backyard either. The neighbor is within his rights though.... unfortunate situation.
  2. rsanden says:
    I wouldn't want that big ugly thing over my fence either!! What happens in the event of bad weather and this new building causes damages to the Oyer home? The city of Turlock should make the builder of this building file for permits just like any structure would require on land. We had to get permits to move a shower drain...I think this building would require more than a drain!
  3. Telemechus says:
    Keep adding more restrictive will really encourage a favorable opinion of this city.

    This city...and country are going down the drain because of stupid laws created by pompous administrations. Enough already. Let people live.
  4. TURLOCKEY says:
    Well looking at the picture Ken Oyer needs to not bring the city of Turlock Planning Commission in on this and just plant a tree in the corner...problem solved. Come on Ken you had 20 years to have a nice shaded backyard and all you did was grow weeds and sickly shrubs.
  5. r says:
    I think the running of a large business out of your backyard might be an issue also. large equipment?
  6. Dan says:
    19 years ago I lived in this house and wanted to do the same thing in the backyard. Back then we had two small boys and had issues with this Mr Oyer over toys coming over the fence. Glad to say I moved away and didn’t have to deal with Mr Oyer anymore. I’m sorry to see that he hasn’t changed and that he is still worried about what others are doing… Perhaps he should do the same and pack up, it worked out great for us.
  7. Turlock says:
    I think a nice shade tree would block the structure and increase the value of his own home. TID has a wonderful shade tree rebate program in place right now.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Recent Forum Topics

Recent Forum Replies

  • Nick on Where to Get Apostille Services in Los Angeles? "Hello. Need to fly to Moldova but don't know how? This is not a problem . I recently flew there with a cool airline. I bought business class tickets at a very low price. I bought tickets here They have fast and safe service, which I really liked. I think I will always use it now."
  • paul on In what different materials do women’s activewear comes? "You may get a variety of fabrics for the best activewear for women online, including cotton, spandex, synthetic, bamboo fiber, and Gore-Tex. Each of these materials has distinctive properties that set them apart. Since polyester is incredibly light and comfortable to wear, we advise you to utilize it. Athletic clothing frequently uses polyester as a fabric. Shirts for activewear, sweatpants and jogging jackets usually contain polyester blends. Polyester often dries quickly, making it the perfect fabric for intense workouts."
  • PaulWatkins on How does a real estate agency work? "Hi Dans Andrew, I'm glad you have made the right decision because a real estate agency is a promising career. Real estate agency involves dealing with properties either for selling or purchasing. When a client comes to a real estate agency to sell a property, it is the estate agent's job to find a buyer. If the agent finds a buyer and closes the deal at a good price for both parties, the estate agent gets a 1% commission from both buyer and seller. This is how real estate agencies work, and estate agents earn."
  • dans on Where can we find the best kratom capsules? "Hi, sir, I don't know which state you live in because many states in the U.S. have prohibited the sale of the best kratom capsules, but you can still find them online. Many online pharmaceutical stores provide the best kratom capsules at affordable prices. You can look for such online stores on Google or even social media. The store will deliver the best kratom capsule to your home without charging the delivery charges."
  • dans on How to choose the right weight loss clinic? "A reputable weight loss clinic should preferably include counseling while being overseen by a doctor or other qualified medical expert. However, some weight-loss facilities allow clients to quickly obtain weight-loss medications and leave without providing a thorough medical history or seeking a physician's opinion. You should stay away from these types of locations because they're dangerous and probably won't result in long-term weight loss. Find a facility that focuses on the behavioral treatment or lifestyle counseling instead. They can provide you with the tools you need to make healthy decisions and advice on how to fit exercise into your daily schedule. Some of these tactics include keeping track of your meals and keeping a weekly workout log."
Skip to content